The council chamber at Valcierre was cold, and it was meant to be cold. The hearth at the far end had been fed just enough wood to keep the ink moving in its wells, and no more. The windows were tall and narrow, set with small panes of glass brought from the eastern workshops at ruinous expense—each one no larger than a man's hand, leaded together in patterns that turned the winter light to the color of old pewter. It was the light of a winter afternoon that had begun grey and would end grey—a light that, like the kingdom it fell upon, had forgotten that sunlight was ever anything else. In the long decades of becoming a realm to be feared rather than a crown to be prayed for, it had worn the colour out of the sky itself.
King Felrian sat at the long table, not at its head but along its side, where any councillor might sit. This was a habit he had cultivated since the first year of his reign, and it still disconcerted men who expected a throne. He was not a tall man, and he did not use the height of a dais to compensate. His authority did not descend from above. It radiated outward from the table itself, from the papers arranged before him, from the map weighted down with stones at the four corners, from the ink on his fingers and the stillness of his hands. He was not yet thirty, clean-shaven in the Valcierran fashion, with a face that was still called beautiful by those who had not yet learned to fear him and was called something else by those who had. His eyes moved across documents with the unhurried attention of a clerk who had been promoted beyond his ambitions and had not yet decided whether the promotion was a reward or a punishment.
The map on the table showed the Aldren Sea-Lands: the duchies, counties, ports, and fortresses that Rydric Aldren had inherited or married or conquered or claimed, scattered across the western coastline like coins dropped by a fleeing merchant. Some of those lands touched Valcierran borders. Some of them touched Valcierran ambitions. All of them were held, at present, by a king who was not present, and that absence was the subject of the afternoon's discussion.
The room contained seven men besides the king. The chancellor, Lord Berengar de Chaumont, sat at Felrian's right hand with a stack of charters before him and the patient, predatory expression of a lawyer. The bishop of Sauvrenne, a man of considerable bulk with a conscience he had spent his entire career learning to manage, sat at the king's left with his fingers steepled and his brow furrowed in the particular configuration that meant he was preparing to object to something and hoped to be overruled. Three border lords—Guy de Lusart, whose lands abutted the Veysin March; Rainier de Montcervier, who commanded the garrison at the fortress of Tor-la-Roche; and a younger man, Josserand de Vaucourt, who had only recently inherited his father's titles and had not yet learned when to keep silent—sat along the table's far side. A clerk, whose name was recorded nowhere that mattered, sat in the corner with a fresh quill and an ink-horn stoppered with brass. And standing near the hearth was Sir Lothaire de Brunel, a knight of Valcierre who had returned six weeks ago from the southern ports, carrying reports already another month old, and who had been summoned to council for the third time, which was two times more than he had expected and three times more than he had wanted.
The debriefing had resumed.
"You saw the Esberian king at Solymer," Lord Berengar said. It was not a question.
"I did, my lord. Before my company withdrew to the coast."
"Describe the siege as you last saw it."
Lothaire hesitated. He was a young man, scarcely twenty-five, with the sun-darkened skin of someone who had spent the better part of two years beneath a sky nothing like the sky of Valcierre. His cloak was still marked with dust from the road, though he had been home long enough that the dust should have been brushed out, and his boots showed the wear of a man who had ridden hard from the southern ports and had not stopped riding since.
"The siege was starving them," he said. "Not the Jaludians. Esberians. When we sailed from Darat al-Bahr, the camp was already eating its own horses. I saw a knight of Montelvair trade a mail shirt for a sack of lentils. The engineers had built trebuchets, but the walls held, and every sortie cost them men they could not replace. The king—" He paused. "The king was thinner than when he left Esberia. They were all thinner. But he was still holding the line. Whatever else may be said of the Esberian king, no man can deny that he remained before Solymer when others withdrew."
Felrian did not look up from the map.
"And did Solymer fall?" he asked.
The question was mild. It was so mild that Lothaire did not immediately recognize it as a blade.
"Not when I left, Your Grace. The latest letters from the coast were no newer. They spoke of hunger, sickness in the Esberian camp, horses dying faster than they could be replaced, and quarrels among the lords over whether the city could be taken before the winter rains broke the roads and the sea-lanes turned treacherous. There was talk of another assault, but no man I spoke with believed it would succeed."
"Then perhaps remaining is not the same as winning."
Lothaire opened his mouth and closed it again.
The bishop of Sauvrenne cleared his throat. The sound was a soft, wet rumble, like a landslide preparing itself.
"The young knight meant no disrespect," the bishop said. "He merely observed that the Lion of Esberia has shown constancy. Constancy is a virtue, even in a rival."
"Constancy is a virtue," Felrian agreed. "So is prudence. So is the care of one's own realm. So is the recognition that a king's duty extends not only to distant holy places but to the lands God has placed in his hands. The Esberian king remained before Solymer. I returned to Valcierre. The difference is not constancy. It is the object of constancy."
The bishop inclined his head.
Lord Berengar unfolded a document that had been lying beneath the map.
"The holy expedition," he said, "was sworn under oaths that bound all its participants. The King of Esberia swore not to attack Valcierran lands while Valcierre's forces remained in the east. Your Grace swore a reciprocal oath before the High Luminary's legate: no harm to Esberian holdings while Rydric Aldren served the Revealed Light in Kedraya. These oaths are recorded in the rolls of the High Luminary's court and witnessed by seventeen bishops, nine abbots, and the archivist of Sauvrenne, who has since died of a flux but whose seal is still valid."
"I am aware of the oaths," Felrian said. "I was present when they were sworn."
"Then Your Grace is also aware that they remain binding unless certain conditions are met."
"Remind the council of the conditions."
Berengar bent closer to the parchment, holding his reading stone—a disk of polished crystal the size of his palm—over the line of text. He was the only man in the room who used one, and he employed it the way a general used cavalry: strategically, at moments calculated to remind the enemy of his advantages.
"The oaths bind the parties so long as the holy expedition remains in progress. If the expedition is completed, the oaths lapse. If one party withdraws from the expedition without the other's consent, the oaths lapse for the withdrawing party. If the object of the expedition is accomplished or rendered impossible, the oaths lapse for both parties. And if either party commits an act that violates the spiritual purpose of the expedition, the injured party may petition the High Luminary's court for release."
"And which of these conditions does Valcierre invoke today?"
Berengar set down the reading stone.
"None, Your Grace. The holy expedition remains, in law, in progress. Rydric Aldren remains before Solymer, or at least in Kedraya. He has not taken the city, but neither has he abandoned it. He has not violated the spiritual purpose of the expedition—not in any way we can prove from letters already months old. The oaths hold."
"Then why are we here?"
"We are here, Your Grace, because oaths do not hold forever. They hold until they are tested. And the testing requires preparation."
Josserand de Vaucourt leaned forward. "Preparation for what? If the oaths prevent us from moving against Esberian holdings, what is there to prepare?"
Guy de Lusart spoke without looking at the younger man. "The oaths prevent us from taking action while Rydric Aldren serves the Revealed Light in Kedraya. They do not prevent us from enforcing old claims that predate the holy expedition. They do not prevent us from responding to petitions from communities that ask for our protection. They do not prevent us from taking administrative custody of disputed lands pending legal resolution. And they do not prevent us from preparing for the moment when the oaths lapse. That moment will come. The Esberian king cannot remain in Kedraya forever."
"The Esberian king," Josserand said, "has already been there for two years. The Esberian treasury has been bleeding into the sand for two years. How much longer can he afford to stay?"
"That," Felrian said, "is precisely the question."
He rose and walked to the window. The grey light fell across his face.
Reading on this site? This novel is published elsewhere. Support the author by seeking out the original.
"Rydric Aldren is the most dangerous man in the west," he said. "Not because he is the strongest, though he is strong. Not because he is the richest, though his lands are rich. He is dangerous because he can make men love him while he is absent. He has been gone for two years. Two years of taxes, levies, dying horses, and empty treasuries. And yet his lords remain loyal. His garrisons hold. His ports send what coin they can spare. No one has sent me letters asking openly for intervention—yet."
He turned from the window.
"That loyalty is remarkable. It is also unsustainable. Love fades. Coin runs out. Sooner or later, someone in Esberia will begin to ask whether a king who never returns is still a king. When that question is asked, I intend to have an answer ready."
Lord Berengar's reading stone caught the grey light. "And the answer, Your Grace?"
"The answer is that Valcierre is prepared to offer stability."
The bishop shifted in his chair, producing a creak that the clerk identified as one of deep and gathering unease.
"Your Grace speaks of stability," the bishop said, "as though it were a gift we are preparing to bestow. But stability imposed from without is conquest, whatever name we give it. The High Luminary's court will not accept a change of language."
"The High Luminary's court," Felrian replied, "is composed of men who write law. Such men are never fooled by language; they are persuaded by it. There is a difference."
He returned to the table. His hand moved toward an older letter lying near the map, its seal still intact, its parchment darkened by years of handling. The seal bore the Lion of Esberia, stamped in red wax that had paled to the color of dried blood. Felrian did not open it. He knew what it said, and he knew that the council knew he knew, and the gesture of touching it was enough.
"Lord Berengar," he said. "The old claims that predate the holy expedition. The council will need to hear them clearly."
Berengar did not consult his notes. He had been waiting for this moment for years, and his answer was ready.
"The Veysin March," he said. "The toll rights at Gisart. The mills at Pont-du-Roy. The vineyards of the lower Sauvre. All pledged as Princess Aelis's marriage portion when she was betrothed to Rydric Aldren, and all retained by the Esberian crown after the betrothal was broken. Twenty years of Esberian administration, Esberian taxation, Esberian garrisons—all of it resting on a marriage that never occurred."
Guy de Lusart spoke, his voice flat and hard.
"The captains in those fortresses haven't seen Esberian coin in a year. Some have been paying their men from their own pockets. Others have let their men forage, which means the countryside is beginning to resent them. A few of the older captains remember when the March was Valcierran. They remember it more fondly than they remember their wives, and they remember their wives well enough to have written letters expressing concern about the future."
"What kind of letters?" Felrian asked.
"The kind that ask whether Valcierre intends to enforce its claims, and whether men who wish to remain in their posts after an administrative transition might find their service recognized by a new administration."
"They are offering to defect."
"They are offering to be practical. The difference is a matter of timing."
Lord Rainier de Montcervier, the oldest man in the room except for the bishop, spoke at last.
"The Veysin March has been an open wound for decades. Every king of Valcierre has wanted to reclaim it. Every king of Esberia has wanted to keep it. The reason neither side has forced the issue is that forcing it means war, and war is expensive, and both kingdoms have had other wars to fight. Now the Esberian king is on the other side of the sea, his treasury is empty, his army is starving, and his brother is—"
He stopped, glancing at the king.
"Restless," Berengar said into the silence. "The word from our agents in Esberia is that Prince Jowan Aldren has been asking questions. Questions about the succession. Questions about the regency. Questions about the cost of the holy expedition and whether the absent king's debts should be paid by lords who have not seen their king in two years. He has not declared anything. He has not raised anything. But he has been asking."
Felrian nodded slowly. "I have heard the same. I wish to know more. Who advises him?"
"A circle of lords whose lands lie far from the ports, who benefit little from eastern trade, and who resent the taxes that funded the holy expedition. Also several creditors, a bishop who was passed over for promotion, and a widow who was once close to Rydric's court and has since decided she prefers Prince Jowan's company."
"A widow," Felrian said. "Which widow?"
"The Lady Ermengarde de Tourens. Her husband died in the first year of the siege, in a sortie that achieved nothing. She has not forgiven Rydric for it."
Felrian absorbed this. His hand, still resting near the old letter, moved a fraction of an inch closer to the wax seal.
"Restless men are doors," he said. "I do not wish to open Prince Jowan. I wish to know where his hinges are. Who lends to him. Who hears his confession. Who carries his correspondence. Who shares his table and his bed and his resentments. When we know these things, we will know whether he is a door that opens toward us or a door that opens toward a fall."
"You wish to cultivate him?" the bishop asked carefully.
"I wish to understand him. Cultivation comes later, if the soil is right." Felrian's gaze swept the councillors. "We will do nothing that cannot be described as lawful. We will send no envoys to Prince Jowan. We will write no letters that bear my seal. We will promise nothing, threaten nothing, and commit nothing. We will merely learn. And while we learn, we will prepare the legal ground beneath Rydric's feet."
He turned to Berengar.
"Begin with the charters. Summon copies of every deed, marriage settlement, and betrothal agreement that touches Princess Aelis's dowry. The originals, if they exist. The copies, if they do not. The witnesses, if they are still alive. The testimony of the witnesses, if they are dead but recorded. I want a complete legal history of the Veysin March from the reign of my grandfather to the present day, and I want it by spring."
Berengar made a note.
"You will also send courteous letters to every abbot whose lands have been taxed by Esberian collectors in the past five years. Do not mention taxes. Mention the spiritual burden of funding a distant war. Mention that Valcierre has always been a friend to the monastic houses. Let them draw their own conclusions."
Another note.
"Lord Rainier, you will increase the garrisons at Tor-la-Roche and the Gisart approaches. No new conscripts. Rotate existing companies so that the numbers appear stable while the readiness improves. If anyone asks, you are concerned about banditry. The roads are dangerous in winter."
Rainier nodded.
"Lord Guy, you will send envoys to the Veysin March. Not soldiers. Envoys. They will carry letters expressing concern for the welfare of the border towns and offering Valcierran protection against any instability that may arise. They will not threaten. They will not demand. They will offer, and they will let the offer sit."
Guy nodded.
"And the High Luminary's court?" the bishop asked.
"We will write to the High Luminary," Felrian said, "expressing our continued devotion to the holy expedition and our hope that the Esberian king's efforts in Kedraya will soon bear fruit. We will ask, with all humility, for guidance on the question of how long the holy expedition's protections extend when the object of the expedition remains unachieved and the expedition's commander remains absent from his realm. We will not demand an answer. We will simply ask."
The bishop's chair creaked its distress.
"Your Grace," the bishop said, "these measures are all lawful on their face. Envoys are not armies. Letters are not declarations of war. Garrison rotations are not invasions. But taken together, they will be read as preparation for conflict. The Esberian court will read them that way. History will read them that way."
"History," Felrian said, "reads what it is given. If we give it charters and letters and petitions and border reports, it will read a legal dispute. If Rydric chooses to read a war, that is his reading. We will not have written it for him."
"And if the oaths are upheld? If the Luminary's court rules that Rydric remains under the protection of the holy expedition, and that any action against his lands is a violation?"
"Then we will abide by the ruling. Publicly. Promptly. With expressions of gratitude for the court's wisdom. And we will ask the court to clarify the ruling. And then we will ask the court to clarify the clarification. And by the time the court has finished clarifying, Rydric will be home or dead, and the situation will have changed, and we will begin again."
The bishop stared at him. "You speak of law as a weapon."
"I speak of law as law. That it can also be a weapon is not my invention. It is the nature of law, and it has been the nature of law since the first king discovered that a charter could conquer what a sword could not."
The fire shifted. A log fell, sparks rose, the clerk wrote quickly.
Then Felrian turned to Sir Lothaire, who had been standing near the hearth in silence.
"You have seen the Esberian princess," Felrian said. "At Solymer."
Lothaire blinked. "I have, Your Grace. At a distance, during a council of lords before my company withdrew. She was armed. She was always armed."
"Describe her."
"She is a knight. Not a princess who plays at knighthood. A knight. She carried a longsword, and she wore it as though it belonged to her. The Esberian soldiers spoke of her with something between awe and fear. They said she had unhorsed Sir Aubrey of Valrens in single combat. They said she had ridden with the vanguard at Qasr al-Hawir. They said she had refused a dozen suitors and would refuse a dozen more. They said—" He stopped.
"Go on."
"They said she was the Lion's daughter more than she was anyone's, and that the Lion was running out of heirs to give her to."
Felrian looked at the map. The Aldren Sea-Lands lay scattered and exposed.
"A knight who is also a dynastic piece," he said. "A zealot who has refused a dozen suitors. A princess who carries a sword and obeys her father." He looked up. "What happens when the father asks her to obey one time too many?"
No one answered. The question hung in the air like smoke.
"Your Grace," the bishop said quietly, "I must ask you plainly. Do you mean to break faith with Rydric Aldren?"
Felrian looked at the old letter on the table. The red wax seal caught the firelight like a wound that had closed but never healed. He touched it, not tenderly and not without tenderness, the way a man might touch the grave of someone he had loved and buried and never quite forgiven for dying.
"Faith," he said, "is a word men use when they want memory to do the work of law. Rydric made promises to me once. He made promises to my sister. He made promises to the High Luminary, to the Revealed Light, to the lords of the west, to God. Some of those promises were kept. Some were not. The ones that were not kept have consequences. I am merely preparing to collect them."
He withdrew his hand.
"Rydric is in the east. His shadow is in the west. Shadows do not hold castles."
He looked at the map one final time, then rose.
"This council is concluded. Lord Berengar, the charters by morning. Lord Rainier, the garrison orders by the end of the week. Lord Guy, the envoys to the March within the fortnight. Sir Lothaire, you will remain in Valcierre until I have further questions about the east. Bishop, pray for me."
It was not a request.
The bishop bowed his head. "I have been praying for Your Grace since the day of your coronation."
"Then pray harder. The Light that hears prayers may not approve of what I am about to do."
He left the chamber. The door closed. The council sat in silence for a moment, then rose. The clerk blotted his pages. The fire settled into ash. The rain began again at the windows, patient and grey and inexhaustible.